When a Hilton-branded hotel in Minnesota canceled reservations for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, it didn’t stay local — it became national news almost instantly. The Department of Homeland Security publicly accused Hilton of refusing service and undermining law enforcement, posting screenshots of cancellation emails and sparking a political firestorm. What followed offers a real-world case study for any organization — including churches — trying to navigate a crisis in a hyper-connected, deeply skeptical culture.
For more stories at your doorstep, subscribe to The Baptist Paper.
SIGN UP for our weekly Highlights emails.
Hilton’s first priority was to clarify what happened and who was responsible. The company made two things crystal clear: the hotel in question was independently owned and operated, and its actions did not reflect Hilton’s corporate values of inclusivity and non-discrimination. Hilton publicly stated that its properties are “welcoming places for all” and that discriminatory actions contradict its standards.
But when follow-up reporting and viral video evidence suggested inconsistent behavior, Hilton didn’t dig in its heels — it acted. The company removed the hotel from its system entirely and began reinforcing clear policies with franchise owners to prevent future incidents.
Now pause for a moment and think about what that means in a church context.
1. Clarify what you stand for, not what you wish people think you stand for. In a culture that assumes spin, ambiguity feels like evasion. Hilton didn’t bury its response in legalese; it stated plainly what the brand does and doesn’t represent. Churches facing a crisis (whether a moral issue, abuse, leadership transition, or community disagreement) must do the same: articulate their core values in plain language and demonstrate how the situation does — or does not — align with them.
2. Own what you can; separate what you can’t. Just as Hilton distinguished corporate policy from franchise actions, churches must be honest about where responsibility lies. If a ministry program missteps, leadership should acknowledge the issue without obscuring accountability behind organizational layers.
3. Act decisively, consistently and publicly. Hilton didn’t wait for the headlines to fade. Removing the property and reinforcing standards showed decisive action. For a church, decisive action might look like an independent review, transparent communication with your congregation, or public apologies — not once, but repeatedly as needed.
4. Communicate early and often. Silence in a crisis is assumed guilt. Hilton immediately explained what happened and how it was correcting course. Churches that communicate early — even while investigations or decisions are ongoing — earn credibility.
A crisis is not the end of your story. Done well, it becomes evidence of who you actually are. The culture may distrust institutions, but it still trusts clarity, integrity and action. That’s a leadership principle any ministry can adopt — and it’s exactly how you tell your story in a skeptical world.
EDITOR’S NOTE — This story was originally published by philcooke.com.
