Skip to content
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • Log In
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Donate
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • Log In
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Donate
The Baptist Paper
Search
Close
The Baptist Paper
Search
Close
  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Your state news
  • Classifieds
  • Request a free trial
  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Your state news
  • Classifieds
  • Request a free trial

Explainer: What to know about Christian baker Jack Phillips and his legal fight

  • February 4, 2023
  • ERLC
  • Colorado, Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, Latest News
Jack Phillips, a baker in Colorado, loses an appeal in late January in his legal fight in a case involving his rejection of a request for a birthday cake celebrating a gender transition.
(Photo courtesy of Alliance Defending Freedom)

Explainer: What to know about Christian baker Jack Phillips and his legal fight

A Christian baker in Colorado lost an appeal in late January in his legal fight in a case involving his rejection of a request for a birthday cake celebrating a gender transition.

What’s the background?

In June 2017 Autumn Scardina called Masterpiece Cakeshop to order a birthday cake, which would, according to court filings, also reflect and celebrate Scardina’s transgender identity.

Jack Phillips, owner of Masterpiece Cakeshop, refused to make the cake. 

He is a devout Christian who has repeatedly said he seeks to operate his bakery consistent with his religious beliefs. Phillips even named the bakery Masterpiece based on Jesus’ words in the Sermon on the Mount, where He said no man can serve two masters.  

Scardina filed a lawsuit against Phillips and Masterpiece Cakeshop in state court claiming illegal discrimination because of his transgender identity. Phillips countered that the decision was not because of the person who requested it, and that he would not create a cake celebrating gender transition no matter who asked for it.

What’s the problem?

The case exemplifies the way LGBTQ activists are willing to use the courts to harass Christians in an attempt to coerce them to violate their consciences. 

Scardina, an attorney, contacted Masterpiece Cakeshop on the day the Supreme Court agreed to hear Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission. In that case, a same-sex couple had sued Phillips because he refused to create a cake for a same-sex wedding. On June 4, 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a 7–2 decision that the actions by the Colorado Civil Rights Commission violated Phillips’ rights under the Free Exercise Clause.

A few months later, Scardina also asked for a cake to feature Satan smoking a marijuana cigarette, which Phillips also declined to make. Scardina later admitted to making the requests to “test” Phillips and “correct the errors of [his] thinking.” The attorney also contacted Phillips multiple times, calling him a hypocrite and bigot, and saying that if the current case was dismissed for any reason Scardina would come back the next day with a new cake request and sue Phillips again.

As Alliance Defending Freedom, the nonprofit law firm representing Phillips and Masterpiece Cakeshop, notes, “The relentless harassment of Jack Phillips — nearly a decade of litigation — has had a significant impact on Jack Phillips’ business. He once had 10 employees and now it’s down to four. He has lost a big part of his business, in addition to the severe emotional toll.”

Why did Phillips lose the appeal?

In ​​its ruling, the Colorado Court of Appeals said the form of the cake, which was to be pink with blue frosting, was not inherently a form of speech and did not convey any particular message. Since Phillips could not claim, according to the court, that his speech was protected, he was in violation of discrimination laws. Colorado law makes it illegal to refuse to provide services to people based on protected characteristics like race, religion or sexual orientation.   

The appeals court also noted Phillips’ shop initially agreed to make the cake and only refused after Scardina explained it was to celebrate his gender transition.

What happens now?

Attorneys for Alliance Defending Freedom said they will appeal the decision of the state court of appeals. 

“The same law being used to punish Jack is also at issue now at the U.S. Supreme Court in 303 Creative LLC v. Elenis,” noted ADF Senior Counsel Jake Warner. “The Court there should reject Colorado’s attempt to mandate orthodoxy and drive views it disfavors from the public square and affirm that graphic artist Lorie Smith and all artists — writers, painters, photographers, filmmakers, calligraphers, cake artists and more — have the right to create freely without fear of government punishment.”

The Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission is urging the court to rule in favor of 303 Creative and will prepare Christians and churches to respond to this important decision later in the year.


EDITOR’S NOTE — This story was written by ERLC staff and originally published by the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission.

Share with others:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Latest News

  • MS Disaster Relief assessing tornado cleanup in four hard-hit areas
    MS Disaster Relief assessing tornado cleanup in four hard-hit areas
    March 25, 2023/
    0 Comments
  • Church in Indonesia continues to worship despite threats to disperse
    Church in Indonesia continues to worship despite threats to disperse
    March 25, 2023/
    0 Comments
  • Edith Mitchell continues to serve the Lord at age 101
    Edith Mitchell continues to serve the Lord at age 101
    March 25, 2023/
    0 Comments

Sign up for the Highlights

Get all latest content delivered to your email a few times a month.
Email is required Email is not valid
Thanks for your subscription.
Failed to subscribe, please contact admin.

Related Posts

MS Disaster Relief assessing tornado cleanup in four hard-hit areas

Mississippi Baptist Disaster Relief officials are currently assessing damage in Amory, Winona, Silver City and Rolling Fork — four areas devastated by the March 24

Church in Indonesia continues to worship despite threats to disperse

A church in West Java Province, Indonesia refused to yield to Muslim intruders’ attempts to stop their worship service on Sunday (March 19), Morning Star

Edith Mitchell continues to serve the Lord at age 101

 At 101 years old, Edith Mitchell has always had a passion for music and serving the Lord.   Mitchell, who resides in Mountain Home, Arkansas, started

SWBTS Old Testament research professor dies at 79

Helmuth Pehlke, senior research professor of Old Testament at Bibelseminar Bonn, the German-based partnering seminary of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, died March 22. He was

Want to receive news highlights throughout the week? Sign up here!

Email is required Email is not valid
Thanks for your subscription.
Failed to subscribe, please contact admin.

About

  • Our Story
  • Our Team
  • Our Partners
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Contact us
  • Our Story
  • Our Team
  • Our Partners
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Contact us

Explore

  • State-specific news
  • Archive
  • Opinion pieces
  • Sunday School lessons
  • Persecuted Church
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • State-specific news
  • Archive
  • Opinion pieces
  • Sunday School lessons
  • Persecuted Church
  • Podcasts
  • Videos

Submissions

  • Story suggestions
  • Your Voice/Letter to the Editor
  • Photos / Videos
  • Corrections/other
  • Submission Policy
  • Story suggestions
  • Your Voice/Letter to the Editor
  • Photos / Videos
  • Corrections/other
  • Submission Policy

Subscribe

  • Subscribe
  • Renew subscription
  • Gift a subscription
  • Start a new member subscription
  • Start a new group subscription
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Hosted Church
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Request free trial
  • Subscribe
  • Renew subscription
  • Gift a subscription
  • Start a new member subscription
  • Start a new group subscription
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Hosted Church
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Request free trial
The Baptist Paper
Address:
3310 Independence Dr.
Birmingham, AL 35209
Copyright © 2023 TAB Media Group
  • Privacy/Terms of Use
  • Help
  • FAQ
  • Privacy/Terms of Use
  • Help
  • FAQ

Email:
news@thebaptistpaper.org

  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Editorials
  • Archive
  • Your state news
  • Opinions
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Persecuted Church
  • Submit your news
  • Photo Galleries
  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Editorials
  • Archive
  • Your state news
  • Opinions
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Persecuted Church
  • Submit your news
  • Photo Galleries
  • Our Team
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Subscribe
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Hosted Church
  • Donate
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Subscribe
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Hosted Church
  • Donate
  • Contact us

Log Out?

Lost your password?

Log In

Lost your password?

Log in

Become a part of our community!
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy/Terms of Use

Reset password

Recover your password
A password reset link will be e-mailed to you.
Privacy/Terms of Use
Back to
Login
×
Close Panel