Skip to content
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • Log In
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Donate
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • The Alabama Baptist
  • The Baptist Paper
  • Log In
  • Subscribe
  • Renew
  • Donate
The Baptist Paper
Search
Close this search box.
The Baptist Paper
Search
Close this search box.
  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Your state news
  • Classifieds
  • Request a free trial
  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Your state news
  • Classifieds
  • Request a free trial

‘Worship war’ continued: Addressing the ‘rabbit trail’ argument

  • February 23, 2023
  • Tennessee Baptist and Reflector
  • Church Life, First Person, Latest News, Tennessee, Texas
person playing electric guitar
(Unsplash photo)

‘Worship war’ continued: Addressing the ‘rabbit trail’ argument

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following column is Part 2 of a three-part series on worship music.

In Part 1, we were introduced to the new “worship war,” a debate about the suitability of worship music based on a song’s origins. We explored the issue’s importance, highlighted some theological concerns, and assessed the root argument as well as some counterarguments. In this article, we’ll continue our investigation.

Further objections

Another objection is that by singing songs with problematic sources, churches sanction that source.

In other words, by singing “Graves into Gardens,” churches show tacit support of Bethel Church. By singing “Shout to the Lord,” they give Hillsong their stamp of approval.

Others allege that by leading or singing a song, they approve of that song. Nothing more, nothing less.

Plus, there’s another angle to consider.

When a pastor quotes a theologian, does that quote endorse the totality of the theologian’s life and beliefs?

I’ve heard teetotalers quote Martin Luther though he was unabashedly a heavy drinker. John Calvin is cited often in sermons, but these pastors don’t sanction the execution of Servetus. I’ve even heard pastors quote non-Christians, not because the sources are infallible, but because they wrote or spoke something deemed beneficial to the gathered body of believers.

G3’s Scott Aniol, an outspoken critic of “those songs,” raises another objection: “When you buy their albums or sing their music, you are financially supporting questionable theology at best, and heretical theology at worst.”

On the other hand, do Christians only engage in commerce with other Christians?

Do we only purchase products from people within our denominations?

The evidence doesn’t seem to support this premise. What company manufactured your church microphones and sound systems?

How about the TVs in your classrooms? Or the computers in your office? Was everything in your church sourced 100% from like-minded Christian companies?

And when we do engage in commerce with a company, does that mean, as Aniol suggests, that we financially support their beliefs?

When I buy groceries at Kroger, am I complicit in spreading their agenda?

How about Walmart?

Can I buy a good product from a store without being culpable for them selling questionable products or having political and moral affiliations different than my own?

And I’ll be totally honest — I don’t have a problem with my money going to those with whom I disagree. I’ll buy bread from a Buddhist so he can feed his family. I’ll hire a Muslim electrician. I’ll gladly pay an atheist or agnostic to work on my car or build my home.

I’m unalarmed, therefore, if a few cents go to Hillsong each time I sing “King of Kings.”

Influencing others

Aniol voices another objection.

When we sing “those songs,” “weaker Christians might listen to other songs from these groups and be influenced by their poor theology.”

Matthew Westerholm, associate professor of church music and worship at Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, counters by suggesting churches don’t “forbid singing Isaac Watts’s hymns upon the fear that a church attender will read the copyright and author … and be led into Arianism,” a heresy rejected in the 4th Century Watts apparently embraced.

Todd Wagner, pastor of Watermark Community Church in Dallas, makes a distinction, however: “While it’s unlikely that many today will dig up Horatio Spafford sermons if they sing ‘It Is Well,’ many people will want to know more about Bethel’s ‘supernatural school of ministry’ because of their excellent music.” Besides, in this Digital Age, Bethel’s podcasts, sermons and songs are more accessible than information about Horatio Spafford.

Adam Stanford, minister of music and media at First Baptist Church, Medina, Tennessee, shows how this influence could be inadvertent: “If we introduce a song that is theologically sound, a member likes it and listens to it on Spotify, then Spotify will suggest similar songs. If it was from a questionable current source, questionable songs will soon follow.”

You can understand why this concern is sometimes called the “rabbit trail” or “gateway drug” argument. Good, harmless music may lead to destructive content.

Where is the line?

How do we apply this standard consistently?

Do we avoid all references to topics with the potential to lead our attendees to questionable content?

Praying for a president could motivate someone to research his political affiliations and switch parties. Mentioning specific sins could awaken temptation and lead to immoral behavior. These are outlandish examples, I know, but they illustrate the logical challenge of the “rabbit trail” objection.

Every facet of worship has the potential to become a sinful “rabbit trail” because Christians are still enticed by sin.

Plus, do we really have the power to ensure church members avoid objectional content merely by not singing “those” songs?

I can watch a video clip from a reputable pastor on Facebook, but just a few moments later, Facebook’s algorithm thinksI’ll enjoy a video from someone I consider utterly insane.

I can listen to any modern Christian music artist on Spotify, but Bethel and Elevation songs will soon follow.

It seems unrealistic, therefore, to think we can safeguard everything our church members confront outside our church buildings — on their phones and computers, on their TVs, when reading books and magazines or even in everyday conversation with their peers, simply by not singing “those songs.”

What we can do, however, is equip them with the truth.

Sing the truth. Pray the truth. Read the truth. Preach the truth. Equip our people inside the church so that outside the church they have the means to clearly distinguish truth from error.

As you can see, this issue doesn’t get easier as one delves in more deeply. There are so many angles to consider that it becomes a bit mind-numbing. Ultimately, local church leaders are in the best position to study these issues, consider their local context and decide which songs aid a church’s worship and which songs are a hindrance.


EDITOR’S NOTE — This story was written by Scott Shepherd and originally published by Tennessee’s Baptist and Reflector.

Share with others:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Latest News

  • Kentucky church ‘looking forward’ after destructive fire
    Kentucky church ‘looking forward’ after destructive fire
    March 31, 2023/
    0 Comments
  • Florida state convention preps for potential reallocation of CP funds, calls for kinder interactions
    Florida state convention preps for potential reallocation of CP funds, calls for kinder interactions
    March 31, 2023/
    0 Comments
  • 5 ways to reach out to immigrants in your community
    5 ways to reach out to immigrants in your community
    March 31, 2023/
    0 Comments

Sign up for the Highlights

Get all latest content delivered to your email a few times a month.
Email is required Email is not valid
Thanks for your subscription.
Failed to subscribe, please contact admin.

Related Posts

Kentucky church ‘looking forward’ after destructive fire

Four days after a fire gutted much of Cornerstone Baptist Church in Somerset, faithful members of the Kentucky church gathered for a parking lot service

Florida state convention preps for potential reallocation of CP funds, calls for kinder interactions

The relationship Southern Baptists have with the investigative firm Guidepost Solutions continues to draw mixed reactions across the denomination. Some continue working through the issues

5 ways to reach out to immigrants in your community

Some churches are partnering with immigrant groups for ministry purposes, others are looking to reach immigrant groups within their surrounding areas. Here are some basic

person in red and black plaid long sleeve shirt using black laptop computer

Study: Should churches ‘count’ online attendance?

With the rise in online church services, many have different opinions on the acceptability or validity of online church attendance for those with the ability

Want to receive news highlights throughout the week? Sign up here!

Email is required Email is not valid
Thanks for your subscription.
Failed to subscribe, please contact admin.

About

  • Our Story
  • Our Team
  • Our Partners
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Contact us
  • Our Story
  • Our Team
  • Our Partners
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Contact us

Explore

  • State-specific news
  • Archive
  • Opinion pieces
  • Sunday School lessons
  • Persecuted Church
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • State-specific news
  • Archive
  • Opinion pieces
  • Sunday School lessons
  • Persecuted Church
  • Podcasts
  • Videos

Submissions

  • Story suggestions
  • Your Voice/Letter to the Editor
  • Photos / Videos
  • Corrections/other
  • Submission Policy
  • Story suggestions
  • Your Voice/Letter to the Editor
  • Photos / Videos
  • Corrections/other
  • Submission Policy

Subscribe

  • Subscribe
  • Renew subscription
  • Gift a subscription
  • Start a new member subscription
  • Start a new group subscription
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Hosted Church
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Request free trial
  • Subscribe
  • Renew subscription
  • Gift a subscription
  • Start a new member subscription
  • Start a new group subscription
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Hosted Church
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Request free trial
The Baptist Paper
Address:
3310 Independence Dr.
Birmingham, AL 35209
Copyright © 2023 TAB Media Group
  • Privacy/Terms of Use
  • Help
  • FAQ
  • Privacy/Terms of Use
  • Help
  • FAQ

Email:
news@thebaptistpaper.org

  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Editorials
  • Archive
  • Your state news
  • Opinions
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Persecuted Church
  • Submit your news
  • Photo Galleries
  • Latest News
  • Trending
  • Editorials
  • Archive
  • Your state news
  • Opinions
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Persecuted Church
  • Submit your news
  • Photo Galleries
  • Our Team
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Subscribe
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Hosted Church
  • Donate
  • Contact us
  • Our Team
  • Manage your group
  • Manage your account
  • Subscribe
  • Start a new subscription at the group rate
  • Advertise and Promote
  • Classifieds
  • Hosted Church
  • Donate
  • Contact us

Log Out?

Lost your password?

Log In

Lost your password?

Log in

Become a part of our community!
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy/Terms of Use

Reset password

Recover your password
A password reset link will be e-mailed to you.
Privacy/Terms of Use
Back to
Login
×
Close Panel